Posts

Showing posts with the label Maintenance repertoires

Possibility vs. Opinion

Image
The strength trough which ideas are expressed affects the possibility of making further considerations or not. The expression of strong opinions, indeed, could inhibit the response of the interlocutor or worse and prevent the development of interesting conversations. On the other side, expressing ideas with a view opened on possibilities, can lead to interesting reasoning. It is matter of using in the narration the dialogic repertoire of opinion rather than the one of possibility. The repertoire of opinion consists in presenting a personal idea and assert its undisputable validity (Turchi). It encloses the dialogical process within the personal position of the speaker, which is not scientifically shareable. Moreover, this repertoire does not allow other realities freed from the anchorage to the personal position. For its closeness and circumscription within the personal dimension, it belongs to the class of maintenance repertoires . Its impact on the narration is really strong, so ...

Comparison vs. Contraposition

Image
Processing external factors or people are natural mechanism of defence because they bring to evaluate the possibilities of danger or oportunities for life (Abdai & Miklòsi, 2016). These archaic processes became the bases for our current process of decision making (Arigo et al., 2020; Milkova, Andreichicov, Andreichicova, 2019). However, considering that making decisions is a mental operation that involves the consideration of numerous variables, leave the choice to instinctive mechanisms is not always reliable. Studies, indeed, pointed out that the more a decision is taken on rational and accurate reasoning, the more useful it it for achieving the goal prefixed (Arigo et al., 2020; Milkova, Andreichicov, Andreichicova, 2019). One of the activities in the process of taking choices is to compare the different oporunities. In the following paragraphs it will be pointed how to maximize the rationality and therefore the efficacy of this practice. Relying on the dialogic approach , the m...

Anticipation vs Cause

Image
The operation of understanding how an event happened and which could be its possible consequences doesn't always have to follow the cause-effect law. As for forecasting , indeed, looking at the future could be limited by deterministic beliefs. In the following paragraphs will be analyzed other ways of talking about the consequences of an event and how looking at the past is generally not generative and productive in life. As previously argued, events follow the principle of uncertainty , or rather everything happens because of casual interactions. Usually, the same reagents give the same results, but this is not undoubted. The cause-effect law got born because of the conviction that the same factors give the same results, but this has always a margin of scientific error. In this stays the difference between the dialogic repertoires of anticipation and of cause. The anticipation bases on the principle of uncertainty, while the cause stands on the cause-effect law.  The antic...

Description vs. Reality statement

Image
The linguistic repertoires used to talk about phenomena are mainly two: the description and the reality statement. Even if they seem equal, using one of them instead of the other changes completely the dialogical identity . Indeed, the description is a generative repertoire which has the maximal generative weight (+1) and, on the other side, the reality statement is the maintenance repertoire with the highest static weight (-1). Therefore, using the description will help to see facts as they are and from them the opportunities available, otherwise the reality statement will close the narration and the view to the statement done. The different characteristics and implications of the two repertoires are reported in the following image. USEFUL QUESTIONS TO DISTINGUISH BETWEEN DESCRIPTION AND REALITY STATEMENT: Which is the rule on which this affirmation is based? Does it have scientific evidence (description) or is it a personal opinion (reality statement)? The affirmatio...